Parenting Perspective
For a child, fairness is often a very simple, visceral calculation based on their own feelings. When a conflict arises, their first instinct is rarely to seek the abstract truth; it is to protect their own interests or to defend their friends. This impulse is born from emotion and loyalty, not from a balanced understanding. They rush to conclusions-‘He hit me first!’, ‘She took it!’-and in doing so, they have already closed their hearts to justice.
Our task as parents is to patiently and consistently teach them that fairness begins not with a judgment, but with listening. We must train them to become ‘truth detectives’ rather than ‘impulsive judges,’ guiding them to understand that true fairness means honouring every single voice, especially the ones they may not initially agree with.
The Impulse to React vs. The Discipline of Listening
When a child is upset or sees a friend who is upset, their emotional brain takes over. They feel a surge of loyalty, and their immediate reaction is to take a side. This feels good and protective, but it is the enemy of justice. We must introduce the discipline of the reflective pause.
When a child runs to you with a one-sided story, your calm intervention is critical. Instead of reacting to their story, react to their process. You can say, ‘I see how upset you are, and that shows you are a very loyal friend. But a just friend is even braver than a loyal one. A just friend wants to find the real truth, and we cannot find the truth until we have all the pieces. Shall we be truth-seekers together and find out what the other side of the story is?’
This simple script does two things: it validates their positive trait (loyalty) while gently pivoting them towards a higher virtue (justice). It reframes ‘listening’ from an act of disloyalty to a necessary act of investigation.
Turning Listening into a Practical, Tangible Skill
It is not enough to say, ‘You must listen.’ We must teach them how to listen. True, fair listening is an active, not a passive, skill. One of the most effective methods to use during sibling or friend disputes is to formalise the process of being heard.
When two children are in conflict, you can sit with them as a neutral mediator. Institute a simple rule: each person gets two minutes to speak, completely uninterrupted. The other child’s job is not just to be silent (which is often just ‘waiting to talk’), but to actively listen with the goal of being able to summarise what their sibling said.Before they are allowed to give their own side, they must first say, ‘So, what I hear you saying is that you feel angry because you think I ruined your game on purpose.
Spiritual Insight
In Islam, listening is not just a polite social skill; it is a sacred prerequisite for justice. To rush to a judgment based on partial information is a form Injustice or oppression because it risks harming an innocent party and participating in a falsehood. Our faith commands us to be rigorous in our pursuit of truth.
Allah Almighty states in the noble Quran at Surah Al Hujuraat (49), Verse 6:
‘O you who have believed, if there comes to you a disobedient one with information, investigate (fatabayyanoo), lest you harm a people out of ignorance and become, over what you have done, regretful…’
The key command in this verse is fatabayyanoo-investigate, verify, and make the truth clear. Allah Almighty warns us that acting on impulse or a one-sided story will lead us to harm people out of ignorance. And the consequence is one of the most painful human emotions: regret. When we teach our child to pause and listen, we are directly training them in this Quranic command. We are protecting them from the spiritual poison of regret.
Holy Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, as the supreme judge, perfectly modelled this principle. He never, ever made a decision until he had given all parties a full and equal opportunity to be heard.
It is recorded in Sunan Ibn Dawood, Hadith 3582, that holy Prophet Muhammad ﷺ was told by Ali (RA) that he was being sent to judge. Holy Prophet Muhammad ﷺ said:
‘…When two litigants sit before you, do not decide until you hear what the other has to say as you heard what the first had to say, for then it will be clearer for you to judge.’
This is a direct, practical instruction in judicial fairness. When our children act as ‘judges’ in their friends’ disputes, they must follow this Prophetic wisdom.
Remind your child that Allah Almighty Al-‘Adl (The Most Just) loves those who are fair. Fairness is not about being the first to speak or the loudest to defend. It is about being humble enough to be silent, to listen, and to seek the truth, no matter where it is found.