← All Topics

How can I show that judging others harshly breaks fairness in Islam? 

Parenting Perspective 

Children are natural observers, and their minds are wired to create categories to make sense of the world. This often translates into quick, harsh, and simplistic labels: ‘She is rude.’ ‘He is a liar.’ ‘They are mean.’ This harsh judgment often stems from a limited, black-and-white understanding of human motives. To raise fair-minded, just, and merciful children, we must actively teach them that true fairness begins with intellectual humility. It begins with acknowledging that only Allah Almighty knows what lies in the heart, and that judging another person without full knowledge is, in itself, a profound act of injustice. 

Click below to discover meaningful books that nurture strong values in your child and support you on parenting journey

Moving from ‘Labelling’ to ‘Observing’ 

The first and most practical skill we can teach is the crucial difference between labelling a person and observing an action. 

  • A harsh label is a final, permanent judgment: ‘He is a liar.’ 
  • An observation is a factual, temporary statement: ‘He told a lie in that moment.’ 

This distinction is life-changing. An observation leaves room for context, for repentance, for a bad day, for a mistake. A label is a life sentence. When you hear your child make a harsh judgment, gently guide them back to observation: ‘We saw that he told a lie, and that was a wrong action. But does that make him a ‘liar’ forever? Have you ever made a mistake and hoped people would still think well of you?’ This fosters empathy and stops the judgment from hardening into a fact. 

Championing ‘Husn adh-Dhan’ 

The Islamic default for fairness is not suspicion; it is Husn adh-dhan . Harsh judgment is a failure to apply this primary principle. We must actively train our children to search for the good assumption first. 

When a child comes with a complaint-‘My friend ignored me on purpose!’-coach them in Husn adh-dhan. Ask them, ‘What is another possible reason for what happened? Could they have been distracted? Maybe they were feeling sad? Perhaps they did not even hear you?’ This practice of ‘giving 70 excuses’ is not about being naive; it is an active spiritual discipline that starves suspicion and feeds fairness. It teaches them that justice requires us to exhaust all good possibilities before landing on a bad one. 

Modelling the Prophetic Standard: ‘Speak Good or Remain Silent’ 

Children will never learn to withhold judgment if they live in a home filled with gossip, backbiting, or cynical talk. You, as the parent, must be the ultimate model of a clean tongue. Let your child never hear you speak harshly about a relative, a neighbour, or a friend. 

When they see you consistently respond to a story about someone’s failing with, ‘We do not know their full story, may Allah Almighty guide them and us,’ or by simply changing the subject, you are teaching them a powerful lesson. You are showing them that fairness includes protecting another person’s dignity even when they are not present. 

Spiritual Insight 

Islam, as a faith, is obsessed with community, brotherhood, and the sacredness of a believer’s honour. Harsh judgment, suspicion, and backbiting are treated as major sins precisely because they are a direct assault on that honour. They are the tools Satan uses to tear the community apart. 

Allah Almighty states in the noble Quran at Surah Al Hujuraat (49), Verse 12: 

‘O you who have believed, avoid much suspicion. Indeed, some suspicion is sin. And do not spy or backbite each other. Would one of you like to eat the flesh of his brother when dead? You would detest it…’ 

This verse, ‘The Chapter of the Inner Apartments,’ is the foundational text on this issue. It commands us to avoid much suspicion, acknowledging that some of it is a sin. It uses the most visceral, horrifying image imaginable-eating the flesh of your dead brother-to describe backbiting. 

When you teach your child this verse, you are showing them that Allah Almighty considers harsh judgment and speaking ill of others to be as repulsive as cannibalism. This powerful image instantly elevates the ‘minor’ sin of gossip to the major spiritual crime it truly is. 

Holy Prophet Muhammad ﷺ reinforced this by identifying suspicion as the root of injustice, calling it the very worst form of lying. 

It is recorded in Sahih Bukhari, Hadith 6066, that holy Prophet Muhammad ﷺ said: 

‘Beware of suspicion, for suspicion is the worst of false tales. and do not look for the others’ faults, and do not do spying on one another, and do not practice Najsh, and do not be jealous of one another and do not hate one another, and do not desert (stop talking to) one another. And O, Allah Almighty’s worshipers! Be brothers.’ 

He ﷺ called it the ‘worst of false tales’ because suspicion creates a lie in our own minds about our brother or sister, and we then treat that lie as the truth. This is the ultimate unfairness. 

Fairness requires profound humility. It requires us to admit, ‘I do not see the full picture. I do not know their intention. I do not know their heart.’ Harsh judgment is an act of profound arrogance, where we claim to have the knowledge that belongs only to Allah Almighty. Teach your child that the most just, fair, and intelligent mind is the one that says, ‘I will leave their judgment to Allah Almighty, and I will treat them with the mercy I hope to receive.’ 

Click below to discover meaningful books that nurture strong values in your child and support you on parenting journey