Parenting Perspective
This is a very common challenge in the modern world. Our children are often presented with a false choice. In some spaces, they are taught to revere scientists as the ultimate source of ‘truth’ and to view religious scholars as outdated. In other spaces, they may hear science and ‘worldly’ knowledge being belittled in favour of religious scholarship.
This can create a harmful division in your child’s mind. They may feel they must pick a side: the ‘how’ of science or the ‘why’ of faith. Beneath their confusion lies a simple, innocent question: ‘Who holds the ‘real’ knowledge?’ Your task is to show them that this is not a competition. In Islam, all beneficial knowledge is a branch of the same tree of wisdom, and both types of seekers deserve our deepest respect.
One Light, Two Rays
You can begin by explaining that scholars and scientists are both studying the same reality, just from different angles. They are allies in seeking truth, not rivals. You might say: ‘A religious scholar studies the Words of Allah Almighty (the noble Quran) to understand His will and guidance. They help us answer the ‘Why’ questions: ‘Why are we here?’ and ‘How should we live?” You can then add, ‘A scientist studies the Works of Allah Almighty (the creation) to understand His design and power. They help us answer the ‘How’ questions: ‘How does the universe work?” This simple analogy unites both paths. It shows your child that both are looking for Allah Almighty ‘s signs. One reads the revealed book, the other reads the created book. A complete person needs the wisdom of both.
Modelling Balanced Respect
Children learn who to value by watching you. You must model equal respect in your own language. It is important to avoid belittling worldly knowledge, just as you would avoid belittling religious scholars. When your child mentions their science teacher, a famous scientist, or their noble Quran teacher, your response should be consistent: ‘Masha’Allah! What an important job. They are spending their life seeking knowledge to benefit people. May Allah Almighty bless them.’ This teaches your child that all forms of beneficial knowledge are dignified and honourable.
The Shared Virtue: Humility
You can also unite both fields by discussing the virtues required for both. The greatest scholars and the greatest scientists share one profound quality: humility. You can explain: ‘A good scientist knows that the more they discover, the more they realise how little they actually know about Allah Almighty ‘s vast creation. And a good scholar knows that the more they study, the more they realise how deep Allah Almighty ‘s wisdom is. Both of them are humbled by their knowledge.’ This teaches your child that the result of all true learning-whether in a lab or in a mosque-is not arrogance, but awe.
Spiritual Insight
The noble Quran and the Sunnah are clear: Islam honours ‘Ilm (knowledge) in its entirety, as long as it is beneficial. The tradition does not create a hierarchy that pits the ‘seen’ against the ‘unseen.’ Allah Almighty, in a beautiful and profound verse, does not define the ‘knowledgeable’ as those who have memorised facts. He defines them by their emotional and spiritual state.
Allah Almighty states in the noble Quran at Surah Fatir (35), Verse 28:
‘…Only those fear Allah Almighty, from among His servants, who have knowledge. Indeed, Allah Almighty is Exalted in Might and Forgiving…’
The word ‘fear’ here is khashyah, which means awe, reverence, and humble fear. This verse is universal. It means that any servant, from any field, who gains knowledge (whether of galaxies, biology, or law) and has it truly sink in, will be led to one, inevitable conclusion: a state of awe before the Creator. The true scientist and the true scholar will meet at the same destination: khashyah. Holy Prophet Muhammad ﷺ did not limit the ‘knowledge’ we must seek. He made the pursuit itself a universal obligation.
It is recorded in Sunan Ibn Majah, Hadith 224, that holy Prophet Muhammad ﷺ said:
‘Seeking knowledge is an obligation upon every Muslim.’
This Hadith is an obligation to seek ‘Ilman naafi’an (beneficial knowledge). This includes Knowledge of the ‘Why’, which is the Fard ‘ayn (individual obligation) to know our din. It also includes Knowledge of the ‘How’, which is the Fard kifayah (communal obligation) for some of us to become doctors, engineers, farmers, and scientists, so the community can thrive. Both are sacred duties.
When your child respects both the scholar and the scientist, they are respecting the two great branches of this single, divine obligation. Encourage them to make Dua (prayer) for all their teachers, saying: ‘O Allah Almighty, bless everyone who teaches me something beneficial that brings me closer to You.’