← All Topics

How can I redirect confusing questions toward reflection on divine wisdom? 

Parenting Perspective 

It is a moment that tests the depth of our own faith. Your child, in their pure-hearted innocence, asks a question that shatters the simple peace of the home: ‘Why did Allah Almighty let that person get sick?’, ‘Why do good people suffer?’, ‘Why did that tragedy happen?’ 

These questions are not academic. They are born from a place of vulnerability. The child is not, in that moment, a ‘theologian.’ They are a human heart feeling confusion, fear, or a sense of injustice, and they are looking to you for spiritual safety. Your response is critical. If you panic, or offer a cold, ‘It is destiny,’ you risk closing their heart. Your goal is not to answer the unanswerable, but to guide their confusion toward a peaceful trust in Hikmah .

Click below to discover meaningful books that nurture strong values in your child and support you on parenting journey

Acknowledge the Heart Before Addressing the Mind 

Before you explain anything, you must validate their feeling. The most important first step is to get on their level, look them in the eye, and say, ‘That is a very deep and heavy question. It shows you have a soft and caring heart, and that is a beautiful thing. It is okay to feel confused when we see things that hurt.’ 

In that moment, you have not ‘solved’ the problem. You have done something more important: you have joined them in it. You have affirmed their empathy. You have shown them that their feeling of ‘this is not right’ is not a sin, but a sign of their fitrah (natural inclination) which loves justice and mercy. 

The Frame of ‘Hikmah’ (Divine Wisdom) 

Once they feel safe and validated, you can gently introduce the concept of Hikmah. You can use an analogy. 

‘Do you remember when you were small and you really wanted to touch the hot stove? I said no, and you were angry with me. You thought I was being ‘mean.’ Did you understand why I said no?’ They will say, ‘No.’ 

‘But did I have a good reason?’ ‘Yes, to protect me.’ 

‘Exactly. My wisdom, as your parent, was hidden from you, but my love was not. It is the same with Allah Almighty, but a billion times greater. Allah Almighty is Al-Hakim (The All-Wise). Sometimes, we see a ‘no’ from Him. We see a ‘pain.’ And in our small vision, it hurts. We cannot see the full reason, but we trust His wisdom and we know His mercy is perfect. He knows the whole story, and we only see one tiny page.’ 

From ‘Why’ to ‘What’: A Shift in Reflection 

This is a practical shift you can model. Instead of getting stuck in the unanswerable, painful loop of ‘Why did this happen?’, which is a question that belongs only to Allah Almighty, you can redirect them to a more hopeful, empowering question: ‘What does Allah Almighty want us to do with this?’ 

This shifts the focus from passive confusion to active faith. 

  • ‘Perhaps Allah Almighty wants us to learn patience.’ 
  • ‘Perhaps He wants us to become the person who helps.’ 
  • ‘Perhaps He wants us to make prayer for them.’ 
  • ‘Perhaps He wants us to see how strong we can be with His help.’ 

This teaches your child resilience rooted in faith. They learn that some questions are not meant to be ‘answered’ by our minds, but ‘surrendered’ by our hearts, turning our confusion into an act of trust. 

Spiritual Insight 

The noble Quran does not shy away from this problem. In fact, it addresses it directly, giving us the only answer the human heart can truly rest upon: ‘Allah Almighty knows, while you know not.’ 

Allah Almighty states in the noble Quran at Surah Al Baqarah (2), Verse 216: 

‘…But perhaps you hate a thing and it is good for you; and perhaps you love a thing and it is bad for you. And Allah Almighty knows, while you know not…’ 

This verse is the ultimate medicine for a confused heart. It does not solve the mystery. It reframes it. It tells us that our feelings (‘I hate this’) are not the ultimate measure of reality. The ultimate reality is Allah Almighty ‘s infinite knowledge. We are being asked to trust that His knowledge is greater than our feelings. 

Holy Prophet Muhammad ﷺ then taught us what the result of that trust is: a state of profound, unshakable spiritual strength. 

It is recorded in Sahih al Bukhari, Hadith 5641, that holy Prophet Muhammad ﷺ said:  

‘No fatigue, nor disease, nor sorrow, nor sadness, nor hurt, nor distress befalls a Muslim, even if it were the prick he receives from a thorn, but that Allah Almighty expiates some of his sins for that.’ 

This is the Hikmah in action. While we see the ‘thorn,’ Allah Almighty sees the ‘expiation.’ While we feel the ‘sadness,’ Allah Almighty is planning the ‘reward.’ 

Encourage your child to whisper when they feel confused or sad: ‘O Allah Almighty, I do not understand the why, but I trust in Your wisdom. I trust in Your mercy.’ Faith matures not when we find all the answers, but when we become peaceful in trusting the One who holds them all. 

Click below to discover meaningful books that nurture strong values in your child and support you on parenting journey