< All Topics
Print

 Are tantrums always a sign of poor discipline or something deeper?

Parenting Perspective

Tantrums are a typical aspect of early childhood growth and do not necessarily indicate inadequate discipline. Instead, these behaviours reflect the frustration of children who are still figuring out how to understand their emotions, express their needs, and manage limits. Young children frequently do not have the words or emotional control to react calmly when situations do not meet their expectations. The combination of developmental immaturity with factors like tiredness, hunger, overstimulation, or abrupt changes can easily lead to an outburst. It is important to understand that some children have different temperaments, being either more sensitive or strong-willed, which affects how frequently and intensely they express themselves. When a child frequently throws tantrums, it could indicate that they are facing emotional or sensory challenges, or that they need more defined routines and boundaries. Describing this behaviour solely as a ‘discipline issue’ may ignore the intricate challenges the child could be facing. 

Rather than responding with punishment, it is more beneficial to identify what might be causing the behaviour and to respond with understanding, steady guidance, and reliability. Providing a clear and organised setting, recognising common stress triggers, and helping children identify their feelings can slowly lessen the severity and occurrence of these outbursts. This does not imply permitting disruptive behaviour to continue but rather addressing it in a manner that fosters emotional growth and maintains respectful discipline.

Spiritual Insight

Islamic teachings acknowledge that not all misbehaviour stems from intentional disobedience. They understand that humans are made with emotions, needs, and a learning journey that necessitates guidance. Allah Almighty, in His great wisdom, has created childhood as a period of both vulnerability and development. He emphasises the duty to nurture children with kindness, fairness, and an understanding of their inherent qualities. Allah Almighty states in the noble Quran at Surah Al Taghaabun (64), Verse 15: ‘Indeed, your wealth and your children are a trial and tribulation for you; and with Allah (Almighty) lays the greatest reward.’ This verse emphasises that parenting is a challenge rather than a straightforward process; it requires Sabr, comprehension, and trust in Allah Almighty.

The example of holy Prophet Muhammad ﷺ shows how he responded to children’s unpredictable behaviour with immense patience. It is recorded in Sunan Abu Dawood, Hadith 4943, that holy Prophet Muhammad ﷺ stated: Those who do not show mercy to our young ones and do not realise the right of our elders are not from us. This Prophetic model suggests that we should respond to children’s emotional reactions with understanding and support instead of criticism. Parents should not aim to stop all outbursts by being overly strict. Instead, their role is to help their children navigate these moments with calmness, kindness, and a strong sense of right and wrong. When discipline is based on love rather than anger, it reflects the principles of Islamic parenting.

Table of Contents

How can we help?