< All Topics
Print

My child is punished differently at school than at home. How do I help them make sense of that without undermining teachers? 

Parenting Perspective 

Acknowledging the Discrepancy 

For a child, it can be perplexing to be given a timeout at home but a detention at school, or to be instructed tenderly by parents but sternly by a teacher. If not addressed, this discrepancy may cause children to question either your or the school’s regulations, or, worse, to believe that rules are unfair in general. Your responsibility as a parent is to assist children understand this difference without causing animosity or undermining authority figures. 

A Strategy for Alignment and Understanding 

Begin by supporting their feelings: I understand how different it seemed when your teacher spoke to you like that. Let us chat about it. Then explain that every place has its own rules. At home, we correct in one manner. At school, they may do things differently, but they both want the same thing: to help you grow and succeed. This framing teaches your child that different techniques might exist for the same aim. Even if you disagree, do not criticise the school’s style. If you must voice concerns, do it quietly with the school and never in front of your child. Your child should see that you respect the adults in charge of them outside the home. This helps them maintain their sense of order and trust. At the same time, explicitly communicate your family’s ideals. Tell your child the following: Even if others correct differently, our home will always focus on calm discipline and understanding. This helps people feel grounded, even when external systems appear stricter. Use these opportunities to help your child develop emotional intelligence. Question: What do you suppose the teacher was attempting to teach you? How did it feel? What can you do differently next time? Helping your child ponder rather than react gives them the tools they need to negotiate different expectations with maturity. 

Spiritual Insight 

Islam supports respect for individuals in positions of authority, particularly instructors, while also supporting justice, compassion, and wisdom in correcting. Parents are trained to manage their children with clarity and tenderness, while simultaneously preparing them for a world that may function differently. Allah Almighty states in the noble Quran at Surah Al Mujadila (58), Verse 11: 

Allah will raise those who have believed among you and those who were given knowledge, by degrees. 

This verse praises individuals who teach and learn, encouraging us to have respect for educators and the structures that support learning. It is recorded in Jami Tirmidhi, Hadith 1920, that the holy Prophet Muhammad ﷺ said: 

He is not of us who does not show mercy to our young and honour our elders and know the rights of our scholars. 

This Hadith strikes a fine balance between the Islamic ideal of kindness and the requirement to respect authority and scholarship. You raise your child to negotiate the world with resilience, empathy, and respect by gently explaining to them that while school and home utilise different approaches, both strive for their betterment. That is the essence of discipline with insight. 

Table of Contents

How can we help?